Verification/Noteworthy Products: Difference between revisions

From Open Food Facts wiki
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
== Products with several byproducts ==
== Products with several byproducts ==
Several lists of ingredients and several nutritional tables; multiproduct packs.
Several lists of ingredients and several nutritional tables; multiproduct packs.
* {{Product|3270160602483}}
* {{Product|3270160602483}}
* {{Product|8712566342822}} nutritional table contains two sub tables for caramel ice cream and the other for chocolate
* {{Product|8712566342822}} : Nutritional table with two subtables for caramel ice cream and chocolate.
* {{Product|3041090027918}} sticks for babies with a table for each
* {{Product|3041090027918}} : Sticks for babies, with a nutritional table for each one.
* {{Product|5054070216996}} yogurts with 2 different flavours => 2 different lists of ingredients and 2 nutritional tables
* {{Product|5054070216996}} : Yogurts with two flavours, lists of ingredients and nutritional tables.
* {{Product|00868860}} yogurts with 4 different flavours => 4 different lists of ingredients and 4 nutritional tables
* {{Product|00868860}} : Yogurts with fou flavours, lists of ingredients and nutritional tables.
* {{Product|8480024819512}}
* {{Product|8480024819512}}
* {{Product|8432089108513}}
* {{Product|8432089108513}}
Line 15: Line 14:
* {{Product|20383817}}
* {{Product|20383817}}
* {{Product|4311596464869}}
* {{Product|4311596464869}}
* {{Product|8711200565306}} Ben&Jerry's classic mix: 4 different icecreams in one box
* {{Product|8711200565306}} : Ben&Jerry's classic mix: four ice creams in one box.
* {{Product|3256224111610}} Bâtonnets vanille, praliné, box with 2 different icecreams
* {{Product|3256224111610}} : Bâtonnets vanille, praliné : box with 2 different ice creams.
* {{Product|3263856691311}} Assortiment de pots glacés
* {{Product|3263856691311}} : Assortiment de pots glacés.
* {{Product|3449860415734}} Petits bâtons de berger
* {{Product|3449860415734}} : Petits bâtons de berger.
* {{Product|7613269351740}}
* {{Product|7613269351740}}
* {{Product|7613035179073}} is a box containing {{Product|7613035596658}} and {{Product|3222270955447}}, to sell them at the price of the first one. It has its own barcode and ingredient list. The same discount was also provided by making a bigger pack instead: {{Product|7613035596658}}.
* {{Product|7613035179073}} is a box containing {{Product|7613035596658}} and {{Product|3222270955447}}, to sell them at the price of the first one. It has its own barcode and ingredient list. The same discount was also provided by making a bigger pack instead: {{Product|7613035596658}}.
Line 32: Line 31:
* {{Product|8000500262283}} : Ferrero Golden Gallery : four kinds of chocolates, each one with its ingredients list and nutritional table.
* {{Product|8000500262283}} : Ferrero Golden Gallery : four kinds of chocolates, each one with its ingredients list and nutritional table.
* {{Product|3021762412280}} : Materne Pom'potes : 4 kinds of products, each one with its ingredient lists and nutritional table.
* {{Product|3021762412280}} : Materne Pom'potes : 4 kinds of products, each one with its ingredient lists and nutritional table.
* {{Product|4000930527048}} : Schinkenplatte/selection of meats: 4 ingredient listings, 2 nutrition tables
* {{Product|4000930527048}} : Schinkenplatte/selection of meats: 4 ingredient listings, 2 nutrition tables.


== Identical products with different branding ==
== Identical products with different branding ==
Line 47: Line 46:
== Products with same bar code ==
== Products with same bar code ==
* Canady Dry and Apple Soda {{Product|3124480000378}}
* Canady Dry and Apple Soda {{Product|3124480000378}}
* Candy brand "Sami Sweet" ( Leader Price): {{Product|7290013316110 }}
* Candy brand "Sami Sweet" ( Leader Price): {{Product|7290013316110}}
* Gufrettes (Leader Price) {{Product|3263853192118}}
* Gufrettes (Leader Price) {{Product|3263853192118}}
* Wheat bran Carrefour Bio : {{Product|3560070522279}}
* Wheat bran Carrefour Bio : {{Product|3560070522279}}
Line 345: Line 344:


== Products with two barcodes ==
== Products with two barcodes ==
* [http://fr.openfoodfacts.org/produit/3344290321344/amandes-crues-decortiquees-sans-marque amandes-crues-decortiquees-sans-marque]
*{{product|3344290321344}}
* {{product|8410223800165}}
*{{product|8410223800165}}
* {{product|8410223607139}} chocolat noir à l'orange - Delaviuda
*{{product|8410223607139}}: Chocolat noir à l'orange - Delaviuda.


== Products without barcode, but with EAN-number ==
== Products with an EAN without the barcode ==
* {{product|3256223671030}} : chips à l'ancienne saveur moutarde de U.
*{{product|3256223671030}}: Chips à l'ancienne saveur moutarde de U.


== Products with strange nutritional information ==
== Products with strange nutritional information ==
There is a label for incorrect information nutritional facts, as linked [https://world.openfoodfacts.org/label/incorrect-nutrition-facts-on-label here].
* {{Product|3335122723382}}: Mix information "per 100g ", "per 100ml ", "g / l"
* {{Product|3335122723382}}: Mix information "per 100g ", "per 100ml ", "g / l"
* Cookies brand " Michel et Augustin" , developed in Paris , formulate sentences with nutritional information and ingredients for some cookies ( not the entire package .) Ingredients "classics" are against full labeled in English , for example: {{Product|3760122961951 }}
* Cookies brand " Michel et Augustin" , developed in Paris , formulate sentences with nutritional information and ingredients for some cookies ( not the entire package .) Ingredients "classics" are against full labeled in English , for example: {{Product|3760122961951}}
* {{Product|6132500680018}}: Presence of vitamin difficult to read (B22?) .
* {{Product|6132500680018}}: Presence of vitamin difficult to read (B22?) .
* {{Product|3367651001303}}: the weight of a sandwich is not specified, but information are provided in the table.
* {{Product|3367651001303}}: the weight of a sandwich is not specified, but information are provided in the table.
Line 375: Line 375:
* {{Product|3461820210425}}: Product with 2.8 g of salt, which is very strange for olive oil.
* {{Product|3461820210425}}: Product with 2.8 g of salt, which is very strange for olive oil.


See also: https://world.openfoodfacts.org/label/incorrect-nutrition-facts-on-label
== Other noteworthy products ==
 
*{{Product|5000242452693}}: "Slow cooked tender prime steak in a rich gravy infused with Guiness beer, baked in a unique Holland's golden shortcrust pie" (21 words, 123 characters) is probably the longest product name we stumbled upon.
== Products to remove ==
*{{Product|5601009942268}}: In response to above, a case like this could also be noted: "Especialidade fermentada à base de soja com alperces (4,4%), sumo de pêssego concentrado (4%) e pêssegos (2,6%) enriquecida com cálcio e vitaminas" (22 words, 146 characters).
See [[Verification/Products_to_delete|Products to delete]]
*{{Product|8901491101844}}: Two ingredients lists, one on an importer's sticker. Importer's sticker is more specific, but manufacturer's list includes an E-code for an unlisted ingredient (160b).
 
== Other Noteworthy Products ==
*{{Product|5000242452693}}: "Slow cooked tender prime steak in a rich gravy infused with Guiness beer, baked in a unique Holland's golden shortcrust pie" is probably the longest product name we stumbled upon
*{{Product|8901491101844}}: Two ingredients lists, one on an importer's sticker. Importer's sticker is more specific, but manufacturer's list includes an E-code for an unlisted ingredient (160b).
*{{Product|9100000819136}}: Diabetic information in nutrition facts.
*{{Product|9100000819136}}: Diabetic information in nutrition facts.


*{{Product|22148186}} : Veggie Aufschnitt in two flavors
*{{Product|22148186}} : Veggie Aufschnitt in two flavors
*{{Product|4311596460434}} : Product by several producers (DE NI 010 EG and DE NI 059 EG) with different nutritions and labels (DLG 2012). Might be they changed producers, but Edeka probably sells enough units to need more than one producer at the same time.
*{{Product|4311596460434}}: Product by several producers (DE NI 010 EG and DE NI 059 EG) with different nutritions and labels (DLG 2012). Might be they changed producers, but Edeka probably sells enough units to need more than one producer at the same time.
*{{Product|4300175075589}} : Mineral water from several water sources (Noe-Quelle, Quintus-Quelle) with different nutrition values. Also only one is "Natriumarm".
*{{Product|4300175075589}}: Mineral water from several water sources (Noe-Quelle, Quintus-Quelle) with different nutrition values. Also only one is "Natriumarm".


== Products with different ingredients in multiple languages ==
== Products with different ingredients in multiple languages ==
*{{Product|3228020481426}} : Italian ingredients are quite different from French ones
*{{Product|3228020481426}}: Italian ingredients are quite different from French ones
*{{Product| 360095230511}} : french does not list ingredients
*{{Product|360095230511}}: french does not list ingredients
*{{Product|5411081003654}} : only german list ingredients
*{{Product|5411081003654}}: only german list ingredients
*{{Product|3155930006015}} : some languages provide more ingredients
*{{Product|3155930006015}}: some languages provide more ingredients
*{{product|4021912006023}} : some languages provide more ingredients
*{{product|4021912006023}}: some languages provide more ingredients
Additionally:
Additionally:
*{{product|5449000011527}} : Swiss Fanta has the same barcode as the French Fanta manu1400 but it looks like (the picture is blurred) that the ingredients are different
*{{product|5449000011527}}: Swiss Fanta has the same barcode as the French Fanta manu1400 but it looks like (the picture is blurred) that the ingredients are different
*{{product|7612100054994}} : Ovomaltine has the same barcode but different Nutrition Facts between FR version and IT/ES/PT version (see pictures)
*{{product|7612100054994}}: Ovomaltine has the same barcode but different Nutrition Facts between FR version and IT/ES/PT version (see pictures)
*{{product|3083680002875}} : Bonduelle canned sweet corn seems to have different data in Russia and Georgia.
*{{product|3083680002875}}: Bonduelle canned sweet corn seems to have different data in Russia and Georgia.


== Products with small item-dependent variations ==
== Products with small item-dependent variations ==
=== Products with multiple possible sets of ingredients ===
=== Products with multiple possible sets of ingredients ===
* {{Product|4810268024313}}: the letter (which is to be found near the dates on the cap) is in parentheses after the ingredient.
*{{Product|4810268024313}}: the letter (which is to be found near the dates on the cap) is in parentheses after the ingredient.
* {{Product|4601512006724}}: same, but no comma ("или" means "or"), and there is an asterisk after the letter.
*{{Product|4601512006724}}: same, but no comma ("или" means "or"), and there is an asterisk after the letter.


=== Variable nutrition data ===
=== Variable nutrition data ===
* {{Product|4607053473537}} and {{Product|4690228010347}} — fat and energy values are printed together with the prod./exp. dates.
*{{Product|4607053473537}} and {{Product|4690228010347}}: Fat and energy values are printed together with the expiration dates.


== Products whose packaging, ingredients or nutritional facts have changed ==
== Products whose packaging, ingredients or nutritional facts have changed ==
Products for which the barcode stays the same, but package, ingredients or nutritional values changed.
Products for which the barcode stays the same, but package, ingredients or nutritional values changed.


* {{Product|3041090018398}}: see pictures of ingredients labels.
*{{Product|3041090018398}}: See pictures of ingredients labels.
* {{Product|4002566010727}} {{Product|4002566010703}}: Gazi grill cheese: packaging, ingredients and nutrition values changed.
*{{Product|4002566010727}} and {{Product|4002566010703}}: Gazi grill cheese: packaging, ingredients and nutrition values changed.
* {{Product|3179142785100}}: Agar-agar package, nutritional values changed (how can I show the relevant revisions?);
*{{Product|3179142785100}}: Agar-agar package, nutritional values changed (how can I show the relevant revisions?);
* {{Product|3228881084569}}: Percentages in ingredient list changed;
*{{Product|3228881084569}}: Percentages in ingredient list changed;
* {{Product|8480017350763}}: Packaging, producer, nutrition changed;
*{{Product|8480017350763}}: Packaging, producer, nutrition changed;
* {{Product |3168930005339}}: packaging, ingredients, nutrition changed;
*{{Product|3168930005339}}: packaging, ingredients, nutrition changed;
* {{Product |20329778}}: brand, packaging, EMB code etc, ingredients, nutrition changed;
*{{Product|20329778}}: brand, packaging, EMB code etc, ingredients, nutrition changed;
* {{Product|4602701201517}}: ingredient list changed between August and October 2016.
*{{Product|4602701201517}}: ingredient list changed between August and October 2016.
Since the end of 2021, we now have specific properties to list products which have been reformulated: {{Property|reformulated}} and {{Property|reformulated:description}}.
Since the end of 2021, we now have specific properties to list products which have been reformulated: {{Property|reformulated}} and {{Property|reformulated:description}}.


Line 456: Line 452:


== Other ==
== Other ==
*{{Product|5600162630807}} and {{Product|5600162630821}}: These are the same cheeses, but one has oregano and yet, despite that, the nutritional facts and ingredient lists are the very same
*{{Product|5600162630807}} and {{Product|5600162630821}}: These are the same cheeses, but one has oregano and yet, despite that, the nutritional facts and ingredient lists are the very same.
* {{Product|8801005306898}}: E964 - Sirop de polyglycitol wasn't allowed in Europe before 2012 (see [http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2012:310:0041:0044:FR:PDF this])
*{{Product|8801005306898}}: E964 - Sirop de polyglycitol wasn't allowed in Europe before 2012 (see [http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2012:310:0041:0044:FR:PDF this])
* {{Product|3191220000530}}: American label found in France
*{{Product|3191220000530}}: American label found in France.
* {{Product|8901161105288}}: American label with Italian distributor label, sold in Portugal without a Portuguese label translation
*{{Product|8901161105288}}: American label with Italian distributor label, sold in Portugal without a Portuguese label translation.
Also see, French cases:
Also see, French cases:
* {{Product|2637412247105}} Ce demi-chevreau a été orné d'un logo "Lapin de France"...
*{{Product|2637412247105}} Ce demi-chevreau a été orné d'un logo "Lapin de France"...
* {{Product|3173287528578}} Oeufs liqueur... sans liqueur...
*{{Product|3173287528578}} Oeufs liqueur... sans liqueur...
* {{Product|3259380115713}} Dans le tableau nutritionnel, on a aussi les valeurs "pour 100 kcal"
*{{Product|3259380115713}} Dans le tableau nutritionnel, on a aussi les valeurs "pour 100 kcal."
* {{Product|5410046013622}} Compote à boire dont le pourcentage des ingrédients atteint 106%
*{{Product|5410046013622}} Compote à boire dont le pourcentage des ingrédients atteint 106%.


== See also ==
== See also ==
* [[FR:Produits remarquables]]
*[[FR:Produits remarquables]]
* [[Verification/Products to check]]
*[[Verification/Products to check]]
* [[Verification/Products to delete]]
*[[Verification/Products to delete]]


[[category:Special products]]
[[category:Special products]]
[[category:Verification]]
[[category:Verification]]

Revision as of 22:34, 15 February 2023

Products with several byproducts

Several lists of ingredients and several nutritional tables; multiproduct packs.

Identical products with different branding

Hundreds of products are only different in their brands and distributors, having the same ingredients, nutritional composition, weights, formats... For example:

Products with same bar code

  • Images of 4 different products have been uploaded for (see product 5901234123457 m). I can't confirm any of these with a simple web search. This EAN code is also often used for illustration purposes on e.g. Wikipedia and Python sample code
    • Terrafrika One Cola,
    • Bridelice cream or milk (not sure),
    • Eggo Waffles
    • "Diamond" dietary supplement
  • 20408466
    • ASDA 15 eggs
    • Crackers goût Pizza Crusti Croc (LIDL)
  • Mineral waters with the same brand and codebar but from different mineral springs (and with different mineral composition).

Aldi's products

Lidl's products

Dia's products

Products with two barcodes

Products with an EAN without the barcode

Products with strange nutritional information

There is a label for incorrect information nutritional facts, as linked here.

Other noteworthy products

  • (see product 5000242452693 m): "Slow cooked tender prime steak in a rich gravy infused with Guiness beer, baked in a unique Holland's golden shortcrust pie" (21 words, 123 characters) is probably the longest product name we stumbled upon.
  • (see product 5601009942268 m): In response to above, a case like this could also be noted: "Especialidade fermentada à base de soja com alperces (4,4%), sumo de pêssego concentrado (4%) e pêssegos (2,6%) enriquecida com cálcio e vitaminas" (22 words, 146 characters).
  • (see product 8901491101844 m): Two ingredients lists, one on an importer's sticker. Importer's sticker is more specific, but manufacturer's list includes an E-code for an unlisted ingredient (160b).
  • (see product 9100000819136 m): Diabetic information in nutrition facts.
  • (see product 22148186 m) : Veggie Aufschnitt in two flavors
  • (see product 4311596460434 m): Product by several producers (DE NI 010 EG and DE NI 059 EG) with different nutritions and labels (DLG 2012). Might be they changed producers, but Edeka probably sells enough units to need more than one producer at the same time.
  • (see product 4300175075589 m): Mineral water from several water sources (Noe-Quelle, Quintus-Quelle) with different nutrition values. Also only one is "Natriumarm".

Products with different ingredients in multiple languages

Additionally:

  • (see product 5449000011527 m): Swiss Fanta has the same barcode as the French Fanta manu1400 but it looks like (the picture is blurred) that the ingredients are different
  • (see product 7612100054994 m): Ovomaltine has the same barcode but different Nutrition Facts between FR version and IT/ES/PT version (see pictures)
  • (see product 3083680002875 m): Bonduelle canned sweet corn seems to have different data in Russia and Georgia.

Products with small item-dependent variations

Products with multiple possible sets of ingredients

  • (see product 4810268024313 m): the letter (which is to be found near the dates on the cap) is in parentheses after the ingredient.
  • (see product 4601512006724 m): same, but no comma ("или" means "or"), and there is an asterisk after the letter.

Variable nutrition data

Products whose packaging, ingredients or nutritional facts have changed

Products for which the barcode stays the same, but package, ingredients or nutritional values changed.

Since the end of 2021, we now have specific properties to list products which have been reformulated: reformulated and reformulated:description.

Some examples of products whose packaging has changed:

Products with a Nutri-Score that has improved over time

Asked a lot by journalists, we should have a couple of examples to showcase:

You can find other examples in the list of products using the reformulated:description property: https://world.openfoodfacts.org/property/reformulated:description.

Products with custom barcodes

Some picture is drawn in the barcode (may need to see the full uncropped pictures):

Restricted Circulation Number barcodes don't seem to be allowed in the above key list, yet, there are cases too:

Additionally, some other products may also look like a case of barcode art, but not having the actual barcode affected, they must be technically excluded:

Other

Also see, French cases:

See also